Melanotan I vs Melanotan II
Melanotan I is approved in another form or use and rated 4/5 for evidence; Melanotan II is not FDA-approved and rated 3/5. Melanotan I has more human evidence behind it. Both are used for longevity & skin goals.
| Compare | Melanotan IThe tanning peptide with an approved medical form — afamelanotide (Scenesse). | Melanotan IIA powerful but unapproved tanning peptide — with real safety warnings from regulators. |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Longevity & Skin | Longevity & Skin |
| Evidence | 4/5Phase 3 RCTs of the afamelanotide implant in EPP led to approval; also studied in vitiligo with light therapy. Self-injected research vials are not the studied product. | 3/5Small, older human pilot studies (tanning; erectile function) plus a long list of case reports of harms. No modern trials and no approval. |
| FDA status | Approved as Scenesse implant (2019) for EPP only | Not FDA-approved; FDA has acted against sellers |
| WADA (sport) | Not prohibited | Not prohibited |
| Also known as | MT-I, Afamelanotide, Scenesse, [Nle4, D-Phe7]-α-MSH, NDP-MSH | MT-II, MT2, 'Barbie drug' |
| How it works | Activates the melanocortin-1 receptor (MC1R) on pigment cells, increasing dark eumelanin. This darkens skin and adds some protection against light, independent of UV exposure. | A non-selective melanocortin receptor agonist. MC1R activation drives tanning; MC3R/MC4R activation in the brain affects appetite and sexual function. That lack of selectivity is why side effects are common. |
| Half-life | Short as a free peptide; the Scenesse implant releases it slowly and is dosed every 2 months | Roughly 1 hour or less (short); tan builds over repeated doses |
| Commonly reported doses |
|
|
| Route | Subcutaneous implant (by a clinician) | Subcutaneous |
| Good once mixed | ~28 days in the fridge | ~28 days in the fridge |
| Top side effects |
|
|
| Lowest price per mg | $1.80 (10 mg vial, 40% off) | $1.80 (10 mg vial, 40% off) |
| Latest lab purity | 99.88% (lot MI0002) | 99.83% (lot MII0002) |
Want a third? Add another peptide. Doses are commonly reported ranges, not recommendations.

